Here’s a question for you: is it all right to give money as a gift?

If your answer is an immediate, unqualified Yes, then don’t read on. You’ll probably find the rest of this post needlessly convoluted and pedantic. But if your gut tells you that there’s something wrong with handing over cash on someone’s birthday or at Christmas, then join the club.

A book I recently read stated that most moral stands are essentially irrational: they’re instincts formed in the emotional part of the brain which then commissions the logical part to come up with seemingly sensible – but ultimately weak – arguments to justify the sentimental response. That’s why, if you try to break down many long-held moral values – such as ‘lying is wrong’ – you eventually arrive at an exasperated cry of, “Because it just is!” And maybe that’s also the reason for my total inability to come up with a truly non-emotional reason to support my strong feelings on the matter of money and presents.

Perhaps it’s partly to do with culture and upbringing: I don’t remember ever getting cash for a birthday. But delve a little deeper into memories and complexities appear. Whilst it wasn’t permissible to give money for birthdays and Christmases, it was obligatory to do so for various Eid celebrations and for Persian New Year. Go figure.

Maybe it’s because money seems cold and impersonal. ‘I can’t think of a gift that’s got your name on it, so I’ll just hand over the sum I’d intended spending on you.’ But what if the recipient actually asks for money? Surely ‘cold and impersonal’ no longer apply, because money is what’s specifically – and personally – been requested.

Maybe, in my mind, money is something you earn for doing a job, whereas a gift is something someone would like to give you because – fundamentally – they’d like to make a statement about their relationship with you. If the word used to make that statement is ‘cash’, then, in my opinion, the relationship is vulgarised and is, perhaps, reduced to some kind of corporate contract.

But the business of earning money casts its own complication over this issue, because many people have a personal rule that they will give the gift of money to people who aren’t earning (ie children, usually) but they won’t do so to people who are gainfully employed. There may be some logic at work there, but I suspect it’s pretty flimsy.

And when you start talking about earning money, then you’re knee-deep in all kinds of social awkwardness and potential faux pas, because very few things screw us up and embarrass us as much as the green stuff. Attitudes to discussing wages and salaries have changed in the UK over the years, but I’m told that in France it is still considered incredibly crude to reveal and chat about one’s income. Contrast this with India, where one of the first three questions you’re asked by strangers is, “And how much are you earning?”

So where does this leave me? Well, certainly with lots of wrapping of parcels which are unashamedly thicker than banknotes. The fact is that I really and truly dislike – and feel cheapened by – the thought of Father Christmas turning into a reindeer-powered ATM… but I can’t really tell you why. It just feels wrong.

4 thoughts on “Green

  1. Its almost as though you read my incoherent thoughts/feelings on the matter and put them into words – I completely agree. I don't even like to pay attention to how much something may cost – either when I receive or give. I was taught its the thought that counts and I still beleive that – and its gives me much more pleasure to give than to receive so I would feel slightly offended if ever asked to give cash rather than a well thought out gift!


  2. I don't like having money as a present, not that I see anything wrong with it from a moral perspective; To me there is no such thing as moral or immoral, these are terms we have just coined to interpret things we like and we dont like. My problem with recieving money as some kind of a present specially from people who are close to me is that I just get the impression that they didnt bother with looking for sth they know I may like. It's more like a soulless act to me, very impersonal.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s